Leaderflip Star Logo

The Leader Placebo Effect: When Actions Fail to Align with Words

Table of Contents

Leadership is a complex and multifaceted concept, often defined by a combination of words and actions. However, there exists a curious phenomenon known as the Leader Placebo Effect, where leaders may articulate lofty goals and promises but fail to follow through with concrete actions. This dissonance between words and actions can have profound implications for organizational culture, employee morale, and the overall success of a leader’s initiatives.

Understanding the Leader Placebo Effect

The Leader Placebo Effect (LPE) refers to the discrepancy between what a leader communicates and what they do. It is akin to a placebo in medicine, where a patient experiences improvements despite receiving a treatment with no therapeutic effect. In leadership, the placebo effect emerges when leaders create an illusion of progress through verbal assurances and commitments, only for their actions to fall short of expectations.

From time to time I have caught myself doing an LPE. In meetings, someone will bring up an interesting idea that is off-topic and worthy of further discussion. So I will say, let’s put that thought in the parking lot and we will discuss that later. What happens? Yup, I will forget about it, and the parking lot ideas and discussions will end up on a flip chart in the office closet lost over time.

Causes of the Leader Placebo Effect

Several factors contribute to the LPE, often rooted in the complexities of leadership dynamics:

  • Overemphasis on rhetoric: Leaders who rely heavily on persuasive communication may prioritize words over actions. This overemphasis on rhetoric can create a perception of progress without tangible results.
  • Lack of accountability: When leaders are not held accountable for delivering on their promises, they may succumb to the temptation of making grand declarations without facing consequences for non-compliance.
  • Strategic misalignment: Sometimes, leaders may articulate goals that sound appealing but are not aligned with the organization’s resources, capabilities, or strategic direction. This misalignment can lead to a failure to translate words into meaningful actions.
  • Inconsistent priorities: Leaders may face conflicting priorities or shifting circumstances that impede their ability to follow through on commitments. These inconsistencies can create a sense of unreliability among followers.

Effects on Organizational Culture

The LPE can have profound implications for organizational culture, influencing how employees perceive their leaders and the overall work environment.

  • Erosion of trust: Trust is a fundamental component of effective leadership. When leaders consistently fail to deliver on promises, trust erodes, creating a skeptical and disengaged workforce.
  • Cynicism and disengagement: Employees who repeatedly witness a misalignment between words and actions may become cynical about leadership intentions. This cynicism can lead to disengagement, as employees question the sincerity of organizational initiatives.
  • Effect on morale: A leader’s failure to fulfill promises can demoralize the team. Morale suffers when employees perceive a lack of commitment to shared goals.
  • Reduced organizational effectiveness: The LPE can compromise the organization’s overall effectiveness. When leaders don’t lead by example, employees may adopt a similar approach, resulting in decreased productivity and performance.

Addressing the Leader Placebo Effect

Mitigating the LPE requires a concerted effort to align words with actions and rebuild trust within the organization.

  • Transparent communication: Leaders should strive for transparent communication, clearly articulating realistic goals and openly discussing challenges. Transparent communication builds trust by demonstrating authenticity and vulnerability.
  • Accountability mechanisms: Implementing accountability mechanisms ensures that leaders are held responsible for their commitments. Regular check-ins, performance evaluations, and transparent reporting can help maintain accountability.
  • Aligning actions with values: Leaders must ensure their actions align with the organization’s values and long-term objectives. This alignment reinforces a sense of purpose and credibility.
  • Consistent leadership development: Providing ongoing leadership development opportunities can help leaders develop the skills necessary to translate words into action. Continuous learning fosters adaptability and resilience in navigating complex leadership challenges.

The Value of Leadership: Asking Staff What You and Your Staff Don’t Know

Effective leaders understand the importance of fostering a culture of curiosity and continuous learning within their teams. One powerful way to achieve this is by encouraging staff and leaders to voice what they don’t know. 

Fostering open communication

One of the key values of a leader who asks their staff about what they don’t know is the promotion of open communication. In many traditional leadership models, there is an expectation that leaders should have all the answers. However, admitting to not knowing something can break down barriers and create an environment where team members feel comfortable expressing their uncertainties. This openness paves the way for honest conversations and collaborative problem-solving.

Leaders who actively seek input from their staff on what they don’t know set the tone for a workplace culture that values transparency and mutual respect. When employees see their leaders acknowledging gaps in knowledge, they are more likely to feel secure in admitting their areas of uncertainty, ultimately contributing to a more communicative and cohesive team.

Building a culture of continuous learning

Asking staff about what they don’t know aligns with the idea that learning is a lifelong journey. Leaders who embrace a culture of continuous learning demonstrate that they value personal and professional development. This mindset trickles down to the entire team, fostering an environment where curiosity is encouraged, and learning from mistakes is viewed as an opportunity for growth.

In this type of culture, employees are more likely to take risks, try new approaches, and embrace innovation. Leaders become not just decision-makers but facilitators of learning experiences, creating a workplace that thrives on adaptability and resilience.

Encouraging innovation and creativity

Innovation often arises from questioning the status quo and challenging existing knowledge. Leaders who ask their staff what they don’t know inspire a culture of curiosity that fuels creativity and innovation. By acknowledging gaps in understanding, leaders send the message that it’s okay to explore uncharted territories and come up with novel solutions to problems.

Employees who feel empowered to share their perspectives on what they don’t know contribute to a diverse pool of ideas. This diversity of thought can be a catalyst for innovation, leading to the development of groundbreaking solutions and a competitive edge in the market.

Strengthening employee engagement

Employee engagement is a critical factor in organizational success and leaders who inquire about what their staff doesn’t know play a significant role in fostering this engagement. When employees feel that their opinions and insights are valued, they are more likely to be invested in their work and committed to the organization’s success.

Leaders who actively seek input from their team members on areas of uncertainty demonstrate a willingness to listen and learn from others. This approach builds trust and strengthens the leader-employee relationship. In turn, engaged employees are more likely to be motivated, productive, and loyal to the organization.

Enhancing problem-solving and decision-making

Effective problem-solving and decision-making are at the core of successful leadership. Leaders who ask their staff about what they don’t know are better equipped to make informed decisions by tapping into the collective intelligence of the team. This approach ensures that decisions are well-rounded, considering diverse perspectives and minimizing blind spots.

Furthermore, acknowledging what one doesn’t know allows leaders to seek the expertise of their team members, creating a collaborative decision-making process. This inclusivity not only results in better outcomes but also fosters a sense of ownership and accountability among team members.

The value of a leader who actively seeks input from their staff on what they don’t know cannot be overstated. This approach goes beyond mere humility; it sets the stage for a workplace culture characterized by open communication, continuous learning, innovation, and enhanced employee engagement. Leaders who embrace their own vulnerabilities and uncertainties create an environment where team members feel empowered to share their own insights and contribute to the organization’s collective knowledge.

Authentic Leadership: Fostering Openness to Ideas from Staff Members

Authentic leadership is a contemporary leadership style that emphasizes transparency, self-awareness, and a genuine connection with one’s team. In the dynamic landscape of today’s workplace, leaders who embody authenticity not only build trust but also create an environment where staff members feel empowered to share their ideas. 

Understanding authentic leadership

Authentic leadership is rooted in the idea of being true to oneself and others. Authentic leaders are genuine, transparent, and guided by a strong moral compass. They are self-aware, understanding their strengths and weaknesses, and they lead with integrity. By fostering an environment of openness, these leaders create a space where team members feel comfortable expressing their thoughts and ideas without fear of judgment.

In the context of being open to ideas from staff members, authentic leaders recognize that their knowledge is not exhaustive. They understand that diversity of thought and perspectives is crucial for innovation and organizational growth. Therefore, they actively seek input from their team, valuing the collective intelligence that arises from a collaborative exchange of ideas.

Building trust through open communication

Openness to ideas from staff members is a cornerstone of authentic leadership, and it plays a pivotal role in building trust within the team. When leaders are transparent about their decision-making processes and welcome input from others, it establishes a culture of open communication. Staff members feel valued, heard, and trusted, fostering a positive and inclusive work environment.

Trust is a two-way street, and authentic leaders understand that trust is not automatically granted; it must be earned. By being open to ideas, leaders demonstrate their trust in the capabilities and insights of their team members. This reciprocal trust forms the foundation for a strong and resilient team that collaborates effectively to achieve shared goals.

Fostering a culture of innovation

Innovation thrives in an environment where diverse perspectives are not only welcomed but actively sought. Authentic leaders recognize that they don’t have a monopoly on good ideas and that innovation often emerges from the collective creativity of a team. By being open to ideas from staff members, leaders stimulate a culture of innovation that positions the organization to adapt to change and stay ahead of the curve.

Encouraging staff to contribute their ideas not only generates innovative solutions but also empowers employees to take ownership of their work. When team members feel that their ideas are valued, they are more likely to invest time and energy in exploring new approaches and pushing the boundaries of what’s possible.

In times of uncertainty, leaders who value input from their team create a sense of shared responsibility. This collaborative approach not only enhances the quality of decision-making but also strengthens the resilience of the organization in the face of adversity.

Authentic leadership and being open to ideas from staff members are interconnected elements that contribute to the success of modern organizations. Authentic leaders, by their transparency, self-awareness, and commitment to building trust, create an environment where innovation flourishes, employees are empowered, and challenges are navigated with resilience.

Exercise | Deliberate practice

This exercise applies to everyone from the C-suite to the core leadership of any organization.  

This deliberate practice is about personal observation and being absolutely honest with yourself. If you are reading this far into this lesson, congratulations because you are seeing something in yourself that you don’t like or you are doing a self-check and want to know if you are on the right track. Either way, grab your journal and start writing down what you see in yourself. 

Start with these parts of this lesson:

1. The Leader Placebo Effect: When Actions Fail to Align with Words

2. The Value of Leadership: Asking Staff What You and Your Staff Don’t Know

3. Authentic Leadership: Fostering Openness to Ideas from Staff Members

If something in any of these three parts caught your eye or made you stop and contemplate your actions, write down what it was. This is a good place to start your personal observation and determine if you need to make adjustments in yourself. 

If you want trust, open communication, and collaboration with your staff, department, or organization, you must start with having trust, open communication, and collaboration within yourself. If you can’t do this with yourself, you can’t do this with your staff. 

The second part of the deliberate practice is to be accountable for what you are working on. This is not always comfortable to do but necessary. Again, it doesn’t matter if you are part of the C-suite or core leadership, you need to find peer(s) you trust to be candid with you. This will result in developing a leader community for yourself. 

This part requires you to do the following:

  1. Be specific in what you are working on and write it down.
  2. Determine how you will measure your progress and make sure what you choose is measurable. Use the SMART goal approach. 
  3. Share with your peer(s) what you are doing so you are accountable for your work. Schedule check-in meetings, usually once a month, and bring your notes on what worked and what didn’t. Your trusted peer might see something that you didn’t and can share a different way to approach something. 
  4. Be open to the feedback. 

To the new leaders

Whether you are moving within a company or are new to the company, this applies to you. Stepping into a new leadership role always comes with challenges. So what we do is bring along our practices which worked in our last position. This is commonly known as baggage. Some leaders I work with don’t bring baggage, they bring cargo. 

I’m not suggesting that you drop off your baggage or cargo on the sidewalk and leave it there. I’m suggesting you put it into storage until the time comes when you have a better understanding of what is going on within your team, department, or organization. 

My suggestion is to do these three parts in this order:

  1. The Value of Leadership: Asking Staff What You and Your Staff Don’t Know
  2. Authentic Leadership: Fostering Openness to Ideas from Staff Members
  3. The Leader Placebo Effect: When Actions Fail to Align with Words

 Don’t ever assume you know what you signed up for. It’s the nuances of the team, department, or organization’s behaviors and personalities that are shrouded in the shadows that you need to bring into the light. Understand the nuances, then you can start to unpack the right tools you need for the job. 

Don’t wait for tomorrow, tomorrow never comes. What you have is today and this is the best time to begin anything.   

Share This Post

More To Explore


Leadership, War, Ethics, and Balance

I once heard someone compare leadership to war and on some days it’s difficult to distinguish between the two. On a good day, we grapple

The 5 Content Pillars:
The Exercises:
Blog Posts Bottom Of Page | Email for Active Listening Workshop

FREE: Active Listening Skills Workshop

 Improve communication with your peers. Free multi-part workshop with video explainer.