Leaderflip Star Logo

As A Leader, Prove Yourself Wrong First: Thinking Before You Decide

Share This Post

In the realm of leadership, decision-making is a critical skill. Leaders are often tasked with making tough choices that can have far-reaching consequences. In the pursuit of making informed decisions, the instinct is to seek validation for one’s ideas and beliefs. 

However, true leadership requires a different approach—one that involves challenging oneself and being open to the possibility of being wrong. Explores the idea of proving oneself wrong before making decisions and its implications for effective leadership.

The nature of decision-making

Decision-making is not merely about arriving at the right answer; it’s a complex process that involves careful consideration of various factors, including potential risks, consequences, and alternative perspectives. In the fast-paced and dynamic environment of leadership, the pressure to make quick decisions can sometimes lead to overlooking critical aspects of the problem at hand.

The conventional approach to decision-making often involves seeking confirmation for one’s beliefs. People tend to gather evidence that supports their preconceived notions while disregarding contradictory information—a phenomenon known as confirmation bias. However, true leaders recognize the limitations of this approach and strive to challenge their assumptions actively.

Proving yourself wrong

The idea of proving oneself wrong before making decisions may seem counterintuitive at first glance. After all, why would anyone willingly seek to undermine their ideas? This approach is rooted in the recognition of human fallibility and the acknowledgment that our perceptions may not always align with reality.

Proving oneself wrong requires a willingness to entertain alternative viewpoints and consider evidence that contradicts one’s initial beliefs. It involves approaching problems with a sense of humility and intellectual honesty, recognizing that our understanding of the world is inherently limited.

As a leader, the ability to prove oneself wrong is a valuable asset. It demonstrates a commitment to truth-seeking and a willingness to set aside ego in favor of objective analysis. By actively seeking out evidence that challenges their assumptions, leaders can make more informed decisions and avoid the pitfalls of cognitive biases.

The importance of critical thinking

At the heart of proving oneself wrong lies the essence of critical thinking. Critical thinking involves the ability to evaluate information objectively, analyze arguments rigorously, and consider alternative perspectives. It requires intellectual curiosity and a willingness to question established norms and beliefs.

In the context of leadership, critical thinking is indispensable. Leaders must navigate complex and ambiguous situations, often with incomplete information. By honing their critical thinking skills, leaders can make sense of the complexities of the world around them and make decisions that are grounded in reason and evidence.

Moreover, critical thinking fosters innovation and creativity. By challenging the status quo and exploring new ideas, leaders can drive positive change within their organizations and communities. Critical thinking also encourages a culture of learning and continuous improvement, where individuals are encouraged to question assumptions and seek out new knowledge.

The role of emotional intelligence

Proving oneself wrong requires more than just intellectual prowess; it also requires emotional intelligence. Emotional intelligence encompasses the ability to understand and manage emotions effectively, both in oneself and others. It involves empathy, self-awareness, and the ability to navigate interpersonal relationships.

In the context of decision-making, emotional intelligence is crucial for fostering an environment where dissenting opinions are welcomed and constructive criticism is valued. Leaders with high emotional intelligence are better equipped to handle disagreement and conflict, facilitating open and honest dialogue within their teams.

Furthermore, emotional intelligence enables leaders to recognize their own biases and vulnerabilities, allowing them to approach decision-making with greater humility and self-awareness. By cultivating emotional intelligence, leaders can create a culture of trust and psychological safety where individuals feel comfortable challenging the status quo and voicing their opinions.

Bring it all together

The concept of proving oneself wrong before making decisions is a powerful tool for effective leadership. By challenging our assumptions and actively seeking out evidence that contradicts our beliefs, we can make more informed decisions and avoid the pitfalls of cognitive biases.

This approach requires critical thinking, emotional intelligence, and a commitment to truth-seeking. It involves setting aside ego and embracing humility in the pursuit of understanding. As leaders, we must recognize the limitations of our own perspectives and actively seek out diverse viewpoints to inform our decision-making process.

Ultimately, by proving ourselves wrong first, we can lead with integrity and make decisions that are grounded in reason, evidence, and a genuine commitment to the greater good.

Exercise | Deliberate practice

In professional contexts, the emphasis lies not solely on right versus wrong, but rather on the adherence to ethical conduct and principles. Decision-making processes are often influenced by both conscious and unconscious biases, which are inherent to human nature.

Work at cultivating an awareness that allows you to step back and analyze your own reasoning and question its accuracy.

I have written about the power of this one question before and I’m going to encourage you to use it because it’s universal. The question is:

What don’t I know?

Additional questions to consider along with the what don’t I know:

  • Am I part of the problem?
  • Could I be wrong?

These question serves as a potent tool in mitigating the encroachment of biases into decision-making processes, thereby promoting a more balanced evaluation of correctness even when being wrong is correct.

If you are struggling with the idea of the effect of being right or wrong try this:

  • Make a list of attributes of a leader who consistently arrives at correct decisions.
  • Then make a list of attributes of a leader who is adept at preemptively recognizing erroneous decisions.
  • Finally, think about how staff and peers perceive a leader who demonstrates proficiency in making correct decisions while averting the enactment of flawed ones.

By contemplating these attributes, one can gain insight into the multifaceted nature of effective leadership and decision-making, fostering a culture of accountability and ethical conduct within organizational frameworks.

Don’t wait for tomorrow, tomorrow never comes. What you have is today and this is the best time to begin anything.   

More To Explore


The Rational Leader – Exercise | Deliberate practice

From the Post: The Rational Leader: Cultivating Self-Awareness, Critical Examination, and Determination Start with one of the five areas listed below to practice self-awareness, self-examination,

The 5 Content Pillars:
The Exercises: